Are You Asking The Right Questions For Banking Advice?
Over the past couple of years I’ve heard more and more about bank and credit union customers wanting their FI to provide more financial advice. A recent post by Jeff Marsico brought this issue up again. In his post, Jeff described his latest insurance shopping experience. In the end, he ended up dropping his agent because he was able to find a 20% cheaper rate on his own. Rightfully so, he felt his agent should have been a bit more proactive and had his best interest in mind.
This prompted him to wonder about customer service levels at financial institutions. He also mentioned that a competitor did a survey of FI customers and concluded that “both businesses and individuals wanted advice from their FI.” My question is, “exactly what advice do customers want?”
Let’s be honest, most people really aren’t overly concerned about their finances. What I mean is, they aren’t actively making and following budgets, tracking their expenses and updating their asset allocations. I’m sure quite a few resolutions were made this year about getting finances in order. But I don’t think FIs are asking the right questions.
For all those polls that say customers want financial advice, I don’t see any that mention what type of advice customers actually want. From what I can gather through online searching, banking advice seems to consist of:
1. How to save money, in general
2. How to save money for specific goals (house, car, education, vacations)
3. Using direct deposit
4. Using budgeting tools
5. Avoiding fees
6. Finding the right checking or savings account
7. Finding a good loan/credit card rate
Now I know that most bankers and credit union employees will happily discuss any of those topics with their customers. But are customers meeting with their bank or credit union to go over these topics? Given the low branch traffic, I’m confident in saying “no”.
However, this brings up another question. How do said customers want to receive this financial advice? Generally, most people tend to meet face-to-face with the person they want advice from. I know PFM can be used to offer goal management, products and services that customers may be interested in, but that’s not really “advice”. Is online a better channel? What about workshops or lunch-n-learns?
If financial institutions really want to go down the road of proactively offering advice, they first need to find out what their customers want. Instead of tweeting generic advice, send out some direct mail and surveys to get their opinion. In this environment, getting to know your customer better can only be a good thing.
Photo by Oberazzi
Interested in PFM? Check out these companies and products:
Walmart Buys Grabble
Walmart recently acquired Grabble, a company that makes point-of-sale technology that ties in with customers’ cell phones. Currently, there is a media blackout on any information about Grabble. However, I speculate that Walmart could be making a push into mobile payments.
I could see them releasing a new Walmart app similar to Starbucks, where customers can tie a Walmart gift, credit or MoneyCenter card to the app to pay for purchases. This could potentially lead a major push into widespread acceptance of mobile payments.
